New York Mets vs New York Yankees Odds

The Mets will play the Yankees on Sunday, May 18th, 2025. Your timezone's first pitch time is 7:10 pm EDT. Check local listings or your nearest streaming app for coverage.

Learn more about MLB Betting with our handy tutorial and guide. We explain money line, total and run line bets. Plus, a great discussion about exotic bets like MLB Baseball parlays and props.

STATE	Bonus
#1 BetMGM REVIEW	New Customers - Up to $1500 Paid Back in Bonus Bets Bonus Bets Expire in 7 Days One new customer offer/Add'l Terms Bet Now 21+ Playable in Ohio only Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-589-9966

Matchup Stats
Captain Shady Lines
Best Odds
Interactive Odds Example
Prop Bets
Team Futures Odds
Team Pages
Team Standings
Other Games Today

Key Matchup Stats

SportsBetting3.com Power Rankings - The New York Mets have a 97.00 power ranking. The power ranking for the New York Yankees is 97.33.
Visiting New York Mets - The New York Mets have a 11-11 record as a visiting team, ranking them 4th Overall for visiting team wins.
Home New York Yankees - The New York Yankees have a 13-8 record as a home team. They rank 5th for home team wins in the Overall standings.
Runs Scored - The New York Mets currently stand 8th (205) Overall, with the New York Yankees ranking 1st (250) for runs scored.
Runs Allowed - The New York Mets are 25th (140) Overall for runs allowed. The New York Yankees stand 19th (169) for runs allowed.
Team Streaks - The New York Mets lost their last game. Meanwhile, the New York Yankees won their last game.
Team Records - The New York Mets have a 28-16 Overall record (0.0 GB National East Division), with the New York Yankees possessing a 25-18 Overall standing (0.0 GB American East Division).

Captain Shady Lines

A broken compass is right at least twice a day.

Avast ye mateys! The Mets face the Yankees on Sunday...in their own filthy den...prepare for the battle of the boroughs!

The Mets be sittin' pretty with a 28-16 record...they be plunderin' their way through the season...showin' no mercy to their enemies on the diamond.

But don't count out them Yankees, with a respectable 25-18 record...they be fightin' tooth and nail to defend their home turf...this be a matchup ye won't want to miss...(SportsBetting3.com) has the odds, bet on this game, review the odds below.

So grab yer rum and settle in for a showdown...it be a clash of titans on the horizon...may the best team emerge victorious on this fateful day!

Best Mets at Yankees Odds

**Best Moneyline Betting Odds**
Underdog New York Mets	Favorite New York Yankees
+135 BetMGM Bet	-160 BetMGM Bet

The New York Yankees are the -160 moneyline favorite. Risk $160 to win $100 on the New York Yankees at BetMGM. The New York Mets are the +135 underdog at BetMGM. Risk $100 to win $135 on the New York Mets. Learn more about how to bet on money lines.

**Best Total Betting Odds**
Over	Under
9 o -115 BetMGM Bet	9 u -105 BetMGM Bet

BetMGM has the best over line of 9 runs. Risk $115 to win $100. BetMGM has the best under line of 9 runs. Risk $105 to win $100. Our tutorial explains more about total bets.

**Best Run Line Betting Odds**
Underdog New York Mets	Favorite New York Yankees
+1.5 -160 BetMGM Bet	-1.5 +135 BetMGM Bet

The New York Yankees have a -1.5 +135 run line at BetMGM OH. They are the run line favorite in this matchup. The New York Mets have a +1.5 -160 run line at BetMGM OH. The New York Mets are the run line underdogs. Review how to bet on a point spread with our text and video tutorials.

Matchup Odds FAQs

What is the moneyline for the New York Mets vs New York Yankees MLB game on Sunday, May 18th, 2025?

The New York Yankees are the -160 moneyline favorite at BetMGM and the New York Mets are the +135 moneyline underdog at BetMGM.

What is the over-under total line for the New York Mets vs New York Yankees MLB game on Sunday, May 18th, 2025?

The best over line is 9 -115 runs at BetMGM, which means you risk $115 to win $100 betting the over. The best under line is 9 -105 runs at BetMGM, and that means you risk $105 to win $100 betting the under.

What is the run line for the New York Mets vs New York Yankees MLB game on Sunday, May 18th, 2025?

The New York Yankees are -1.5 +135 run line favorites at BetMGM, while the New York Mets are +1.5 -160 run line underdogs at BetMGM.

MLB Odds Example

MLB Odds and Outcomes Explained
Game	BetMGM Bet
Mets Yankees 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	+135 -160

Bet $100 at BetMGM Ohio
21+ Playable in Ohio only
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-589-9966

Possible Moneyline Outcomes

New York Mets bettors risk $100 to win $135 at +135 odds. The implied probability for New York Mets is 42.55%.
New York Yankees bettors risk $100 to win $62.5 at -160 odds. The implied probability for New York Yankees is 61.54%.

New York Mets at New York Yankees Prop Bets

MLB Prop Bets
+ Displays more odds
	BetMGM Bet
Mets Yankees First Team to Score 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	-120 -105 Bet
Mets Yankees Tie 1st Inning Winner 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	+320 +220 -110 Bet
Mets Yankees Tie First 3 Innings Winner 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	+180 -102 +350 Bet
Mets Yankees To Extra Innings 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	Yes +800 No -1400 Bet
	BetMGM
Mets Yankees 1st Team to Score Will Win 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	Yes -250 No +190 Bet
Mets Total Runs NYM at NYY 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	3.5 o -150 3.5 u +115 Bet
Yankees Total Runs NYM at NYY 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	4.5 o -125 4.5 u -102 Bet
David Peterson Strikeouts Thrown NYM at NYY 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	4.5 o -160 4.5 u +120 Bet
	BetMGM
Max Fried Strikeouts Thrown NYM at NYY 5/18/25 7:10pm EDT	5.5 o -130 5.5 u +100 Bet

New York Mets & New York Yankees Futures Odds

Latest World Series odds, if available, for each team. Review odds for other teams and learn how to bet on the tournament. See past Championship results and learn how to bet World Series teasers, props and parlays.

New York Mets World Series Odds

2025 New York Mets World Series Odds
Team	BetMGM
Mets	+800 Bet

New York Yankees World Series Odds

2025 New York Yankees World Series Odds
Team	BetMGM
Yankees	+550 Bet

New York Mets & New York Yankees Team Pages

Review each team's season win total odds, futures odds, betting bonuses and other valuable information on our exclusive team betting odds pages. Team betting odds and stats update throughout the season:

Team Standings

2025 MLB Regular Season Standings - New York Mets, New York Yankees
Team	W	L	Pct	GB	Home	Away	RS	RA	Diff	Strk	L10
New York Yankees	33	20	0.623	+1.5	18-9	15-11	301	190	+111	W3	8-2
New York Mets	33	21	0.611	+2.0	20-6	13-15	233	173	+60	W3	5-5

How to Bet on the Game

Time needed: 4 minutes.

How to Bet on the New York Mets vs New York Yankees MLB Game

Open a new sports betting account before game time.
Review our list of sports betting sites. Open a new account before the game starts on Sunday, May 18th, 2025 at 7:10 pm EDT, making sure to enter all your personal details correctly. Don't forget to add your bonus code.
Visit the sportsbook’s cashier, banking, or deposit page.
Navigate to the sportsbook's deposit page. Use your Visa card or MasterCard, or deposit with a bank transfer, or other methods like Paypal.
Tap to the sportsbook's MLB page, look for the New York Mets vs New York Yankees Game.
Navigate to the sportsbook's MLB page. Next, look for live or upcoming matchups. Select the New York Mets vs New York Yankees Game.
Choose your bet and place a wager.
Choose your bet and then use the funds you deposited to place a wager. The sportsbook will pay your winnings or deduct a losing wager from your account balance after the game.

Other May 18, 2025 MLB Games

Odds Preview 12640

Table of Contents